Last September, as The Oldham Era reported, Jamie Reed walked back onto the South Oldham High School field wearing a different color than the one Crestwood remembered. Reed had coached the Dragons before taking the head job at Oldham County, and the September 19, 2025 meeting between the two programs was his first shot at his old team. The game itself lived up to the moment: South Oldham held on, 14-11, in what local coverage called an instant classic, extending the Dragons' win streak in the series to four games running. Afterward, Reed put his own return in plain terms in comments reported by The Oldham Era.
"It's not really a homecoming until you retire. Now, we're the enemy at the other schools."
The Oldham Era also reported his further remarks, which sounded like a man trying to close a chapter before it got any longer. He said he hoped the next meeting would just be football, decided on the field and nothing else, so that "next year, there won't be a story, it'll just be the Colonels versus the Dragons."
That is not quite how this September went. The story didn't disappear. It just changed which side it was written for.
Three Close Games in Three Years
Line up the last three meetings between these two programs and something becomes visible that has nothing to do with who was favored. In 2024, playing at Oldham County's field in Buckner, South Oldham won 23-21, a two-point game. In 2025, back home in Crestwood, the Dragons won again, 14-11, a three-point game. This year, on the road at Oldham County, South Oldham lost 14-12, a two-point game, the same margin as 2024, just landing on the opposite side.
South Oldham won the first two; Oldham County won this year. If Reed was hoping the rivalry would stop being a story, the numbers argue the opposite: it has been the same story for three years running, tight enough to turn on a single defensive stop, and this was simply the year Oldham County was the team making that stop.
A Season That Was Already Sliding Before the Rivalry Game
South Oldham didn't arrive at that Oldham County game with momentum to spend. A week earlier, on September 11, the Dragons had lost to North Oldham by 42 points, their roughest outing of the young season. The rivalry game snapped the margin back to something recognizable, a two-point loss instead of a blowout, but it didn't snap the losing streak. The 14-12 result made it four defeats in a row and dropped South Oldham to 1-4, with its only win a defensive 8-0 decision over Meade County back on August 21.
District play opened the following week, and the slide continued. On September 25, South Oldham hosted Anderson County to start conference play and lost 28-20, the Dragons' highest-scoring output of the season and their fifth straight loss regardless. That defeat carried its own local marker: it was South Oldham's seventh consecutive loss at its own stadium, a stretch that goes back into last season.
Reed's comment about there being no more story reads differently now than it probably did the night he said it. He meant his own homecoming would stop being the headline, and it has. But the rivalry kept making noise anyway, just through the scoreline instead of the storyline, and it did so in the middle of a losing stretch that has nothing to do with him at all.
A year earlier, facing a similar gut-punch loss to North Oldham, head coach Cain Sams described what a program does in that exact spot in comments reported by The Oldham Era.
"It happens all the time in sports, one really tough, emotional loss can easily lead to two, and you can almost feel like you could lose control."
His staff met until midnight that week, by his own account, and spent the days after focused on discipline before anything else. That version of the story ended with the win over Oldham County that stretched the Dragons' streak to four. This year, the same kind of loss to North Oldham came first again. The response landed on the other side of the coin: the tight loss to the Colonels, followed by a district-opening loss to Anderson County.
What's Left to Watch This Fall
The district schedule is still mostly ahead of South Oldham, and it doesn't get easier right away. The Dragons host Woodford County on October 2 in their second conference game. Woodford County comes in ranked 20th in MaxPreps' Kentucky computer rankings against South Oldham's 132nd, the widest gap the Dragons have faced on paper all season. After that, South Oldham travels to Scott County on October 9 and to Collins on October 23 to close out the year.
None of those three games is the rivalry game. All three will decide whether 1-5 turns out to be the season's headline or just its midpoint.
South Oldham High School has fielded the Dragons since 1989, green, navy, and grey under the lights on Highway 329, and the record on any given Friday hasn't changed where the game gets played or when it kicks off. The losing streak changes what the parking lot sounds like at 10:30 on a Friday night. It hasn't changed the schedule, and it hasn't moved the rivalry any further from the surface than it's ever been.
We'll be watching to see whether Woodford County extends the skid or breaks it. If you're headed out to Highway 329 this Friday, Dee Amber Homes will see you in the stands.